By Dr. Gina Maccarone, MD, FACS, FAACS

In today’s world, we’re seeing a rise in facial rejuvenation procedures, and it makes sense. With the way we live on camera these days (Zoom calls, social media, selfies), it’s no surprise that many women and men are looking for ways to feel more refreshed and confident. But as the demand grows, so does the confusion around what procedures actually do. One question I hear all the time: “What’s the difference between a facelift and a ponytail lift?” While the ponytail lift may sound trendier or less invasive, it’s important to understand how the two differ, and which one may be the right fit for your goals.
The “ponytail lift” is not a medically defined procedure. In fact, it’s a term used in marketing to describe various techniques that aim to create a lifted look, usually with minimal downtime and little to no visible scarring. Sounds great, right? But here’s the reality: most ponytail lifts do not address deeper facial structures, like the SMAS layer, which are key to truly lifting and rejuvenating the face. Instead, these procedures often rely on skin tightening or subtle adjustments in the temple or brow area. The results can be subtle and short-lived, which can be ideal for certain patients, but definitely not a substitute for a full facelift.
A true facelift is a surgical procedure that repositions not just the skin, but also the underlying tissue and muscles of the face. It’s designed to restore the natural contours of the mid-face, jawline, and neck, offering longer-lasting and more comprehensive results. When done with care and precision, a facelift shouldn’t make you look different. It should make you look like you, just more refreshed and rested. And while it does require more recovery time than a “mini” or ponytail lift, the tradeoff is longevity and real transformation.
One of the biggest misconceptions I hear is that facelifts are “too aggressive” or that a ponytail lift is “just as effective” with less downtime. The truth is, your results will only be as good as the technique used, and the technique should always be matched to your anatomy and your aging process. There’s no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to facial rejuvenation. What works beautifully for one patient might not be the right choice for another. That’s why every consultation in my practice is built on education, conversation, and customized planning.
If you’re exploring facial surgery, my advice is this: don’t choose a procedure because it sounds trendy or quick. Choose it because it’s right for you. Ask questions. Understand what structures are being lifted, what kind of results you can expect over time, and what recovery will realistically look like. Whether you’re in your late 30s starting to see early signs of aging, or in your 50s or 60s seeking a more defined, youthful contour, your goals deserve a thoughtful, experienced approach.
My mission as a surgeon is never to sell a procedure. It’s to support you in making confident, empowered decisions about your face and your future. Whether I recommend a facelift, volume restoration, or a smaller lift based on your goals, you’ll always get the full picture from me. No trends, just transparency and truth. You only get one face. Let’s treat it with the care, respect, and artistry it deserves.
Xo,
Dr. G.